koined wrote:It looks like Blue and Rungan are tied for the lead, followed by Molotavcocktail and Antariticas!

Yep indeed.
Did you vote anyone koined?

Can I vote?

Sure why not.

Blue2Volf wrote:

koined wrote:It looks like Blue and Rungan are tied for the lead, followed by Molotavcocktail and Antariticas!

Yep indeed.
Did you vote anyone koined?

Yep though I voted DragonFangBoot I liked the it's designed like a chopper, your's is excellent, but I like how Antartica's looked a little better.

I voted for Molotov, but I think some of entries that arent in the finalists should have been, no offense to the finalists.

Lol seven is my fav number and Im 7th finalist.

Congrats to all the finalists! Good luck everyone.

MaxisCactus wrote:
As long as your sub was tagged with mcsubmarinechallenge it was considered for this challenge.

I didn't...
Well, there is always next time...
I also just voted.

Congratulations to all the finalists!

The Penguin gets my vote...

I just had to vote for the penguin though molotovcoketails was my second favorite

12 creations , 20 hours of work design finding unique ideas and I lost against a penguin.
My superior warmachines failed at charming.

I have, over the past month, spent a great deal of time and effort as I built the McSubmarines Unlimited Sporecast pointing out to people that they needed both a link to and a picture of their creations in order to have their submarines entered into the challenge. This was not from a "I know how to do this and you're doing it wrong" aire of superiority, but because I didn't want anyone to have their submarines not considered for the challenge because of a simple mistake. I pointed people to tutorials to teach them how to post images and links so often I was begining to feel as though I was spamming the thread, after all the rules clearly stated...

MaxisCactus wrote:• To submit a creation: publish it with the tag mcsubmarinechallenge and post a picture and link to it here on the forum

No one has ever contradicted me as I pointed out that you need a link and a pic or when I have said that you might be lucky as long as you have, at a very minimum, a link to your submarines Sporepedia detail page.

Then, today, after the contest is closed I see this post...

MaxisCactus wrote:

KangiusGore wrote:Um? I made a sub for this last night but I didn't say anything on the forum... Did I have to state my entry here to enter?

As long as your sub was tagged with mcsubmarinechallenge it was considered for this challenge.

I would have said that this was mistaken as it says in the rules.... except for two things,

It was MaxisCactus (and the full weight of her authority) that said it.

The first Submarine finalist out of the gate had neither image nor link posted to this thread

So it would seem that I have spent most of the past month wasting my time, it would have been nice if MC could have either said that earlier or not said the exact opposite in the rules then, maybe I could have used that time on something more constructive.

It also leads me to wonder which submarines were actually considered for the finals, as of my last place marker the McSubmarines Unlimited Sporecast had over 240 entries (with possibly a couple of dozen additional subs from the thread not included because they did not have valid links) yet a search of the Sporpedia for the mclegendschallenge tag yielded only 119 submarines. Were the other 100+ considered?

Please, do not take this as a complaint against the submarines that were selected to be finalists, it is not, they are all wonderful creations and deserve to be there and I wish all of them luck in the voting.

Frog

nevermind.

Holy crap! Last night Mavor had 5 votes when I fell asleep, now he has 21, thats tough to beat.

That penguin sub looks great, so I voted for it.